Does Strength Training Boost Your Metabolism?


Fitness:

I've seen exaggerated claims pro and con about the question of strength training and metabolism. Some authors imply that if you pump iron for a week or two you'll be able to pound down an extra Big Mac and quart of ice cream per day.

The most pessimistic authors declare that there is almost no increase in metabolism from strength training. In the middle the statement that gaining an extra pound of muscle boosts metabolism by about 50 calories per day is often made. So who's right?

The 50 calorie per day notion comes from looking at studies like that by Campbell, et al [Campbell, 1994], which showed about a 7% increase in metabolims among participants in a 12 week resistance training program.

This amounts to around 150 calories per day, and the participants gained on average about 3 pounds of muscle, so it appears that each pound of muscle boosted metabolism by 50 calories per day. Similar results have been found in other studies, e.g. [Pratley, 1995].

On the other hand, the calorie consumption of muscle has been directly measured and found to be about 6 calories per pound per day[McClave, 2001]. Further, each pound of fat burns up 2 calories per day, so if you lose a pound of fat and gain a pound of muscle there should only be a net boost in your metabolism of 4 calories per day, as one author put it, maybe enough for a celery stick.

Based on this result, science writer Gina Kolata in her book claimed that strength training does not boost metabolism Ultimate Fitness [Kolata, 2003], and similar reasoning was used in an article in Runner's World by well-known running writer Amby Burfoot.

The two results, both from careful scientific studies, seem to present a paradox. But it turns out the 50 calorie per day argument is a misinterpretation of the Campbell results. It's not that 3 extra pounds of muscle boosted the participants metabolism 7%, instead the strength training revved up all their muscle, leading to a significant increase in resting metabolic rate (RMR).

This was stated by the authors of the Campbell study, who never made the 50 calorie per pound per day claim: "The increase in RMR is due to an increase in the metabolic activity of lean tissue and not an increase in the amount of lean tissue mass". [Campbell, 1994]. Various factors may cause this increase, including repair of tissue damage, increased protein synthesis, etc. Using the 6 calorie per pound per day result as justification that there is very little increase in metabolism is also a misinterpretation, again based on the wrong assumption that it's the extra pounds of muscle that matter.

So strength training will increase your metabolism, by making all your muscles a bit more active. This revving up lasts at least a couple of days after training- the 7% boost mentioned above was measured 45 hours after the participants' last training session.

Personally its not my main reason for doing it, I'm after things like bone health and fighting off age-related decline in muscle. But I don't mind any help my metabolically challenged old body can get.

References
-Campbell, W, Crim, M, Young, V, and Evans, W.
"Increased Energy Requirements and Changes in Body Composition With Resistance Training in Older Adults", American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,60: 167, 1994.

-Kolata, G, Ultimate Fitness: The Quest for Truth about Health and Exercise, Farrar Straus Giroux, 2003.

-McClave, Stephen A.; Snider, Harvy L., "Dissecting The Energy Needs Of The Body", Current Opinion In Clinical Nutrition And Metabolic Care, 4(2):143-147, 2001.

-Pratley R, et al, "Strength Training Increases Resting Metabolic Rate And Norepinephrine Levels In Healthy 50- To 65-yr-old Men", J. Appl Physiol., 79(3):818-23, 1995.

I'm Richard King, 54 and a mechanical engineer with a Ph.D. from Stanford. Biking and fitness are my main hobby, and I am well versed in biomechanics and exercise physiology through many years of reading and research.My website is www.bikeandfit.com.


Hot Topics In Fitness

    Simple Dermatology Answers To Cystic Acne

    Being exposed to the ravages of acne at some point in life is common, cystic acne appears to be for the most part genetic. If you had a nurturer with cystic acne you may experience a higher risk as we...

    Will and Mind Control

    Control of the mind is a very interesting inner game. If you have a sportsman attitude you will thoroughly enjoy it, even apparently if it seems that you are losing. It takes a great deal of skill, al...

    Top Foods For Bigger Muscle Gain

    What do you do to get a hard lean body Not hours and hours in the gym that will help you a bit but the main thing is what you are pouring into your stomach. You may want to get some ideas on healthy ...

    How Do I Find Discount Gym Equipment?

    A great way to get that new gym you've been looking for is to find home gyms at yard sales. This opportunity is a great one that is often overlooked. Yet it's quite simple to find home gyms at yard sa...

    How Protein Build Muscles | When To Take Protein?

    If you want to build muscles, you must eat protein. Without the amino acids protein provides, your muscles won't grow no matter how you train them. Protein is your muscle's building block and there ar...

    High Protein Diet to Build Muscle

    Do you want to build muscle? Well if you do then you must include a high protein diet into your daily food intake to really be able to build muscle. So what diets do bodybuilders use? They use a high ...

    Home Gyms: More Convenient Than a Membership

    Do you have problem areas? Would you like to lose a few pounds? Most people would answer yes to this question. But who really has the time? Most people today do not have the time to go to the gym. Wor...

    Best Elliptical Machine Tips To Save You Money

    In the history of fitness and aerobics, elliptical machines are the only aerobic products that have made a major breakthrough. The elliptical machine is quickly gaining popularity both in and out of t...

    Start Your New Year Right With the Proper Home Exercise Fitness Program

    For more and more people, home exercise fitness equipment has become a way of life, a must-have item. And, the range of home fitness equipment available is, frankly, staggering. It can be hard to know...

    Pregnancy Diet And Exercise - What Should I Know About Pregnancy And Exercise?

    During pregnancy it is in fact healthy for expectant women to exercise provided it is done in the proper manner.

    Mild exercise appropriate to the various stages has several advantages.It helps to st...

    You Don't Lose More Fat Exercising Before Breakfast

    You will sometimes see it recommended to exercise before eating breakfast, so that you will burn more fat. This is based on a similar misconception to the idea that there is an ideal "fat burn zone" o...

    What To Look For In Sports Training Equipment?

    When it comes to sports and training, sports training equipment is a great idea to take advantage of. There are so many different brands and types to choose from, but once you find one, the advantages...

Most Recent Fitness Supplements

Interesting Today:

Most Recent Fitness Blogs:

Releated to Fitness:

Fitness Links:

Fitness Fitness Rss feeds.