The Great Implant Debate

Breast implants are a popular area of plastic surgery. This leads us to the debate on the type of implants that are best and the government's role in the decision

The Great Implant Debate

The debate on silicone and saline implants is a hot one. For a long period of time, silicone was dominant, but health concerns led to saline coming to the front.

Silicone first became a popular enlargement resource after World War II. Doctors would shoot silicone directly into women's breasts to create enlargement. This direct approach resulted in numerous complications including cysts, sores and systematic illness. These complications led to the reduction of interest in silicone, but it would make a comeback.

In the early 1960s, two Houston plastic surgeons developed the first contained silicone implants with Dow Corning. To say the two plastic surgeons, Thomas Cronin and Frank Gerow, revolutionized plastic surgery would be a minor understatement. The procedure because very popular and there was practically more demand than there were plastic surgeons to satisfy it.

The implant was made of a harder silicone sack covering soft silicone gel. The implant was very popular because it held form better than saline implants. The implants, however, were not regulated at the time. As time passed, the Federal Drug Administration was given oversight and concerns started to arise regarding problems associated with leaks or complete failures of the implants. This was particularly true for second generation implants which were designed to be as soft as possible per surgeon requests, a situation that led them to be very thin and result in failures. One version had a polyurethane coating that actually degraded into a carcinogen, a product quickly pulled from the market.

The debate on silicone implants is heated, but surprisingly bereft of facts. What is clear is silicone implants leak silicone into the body. Silicone in the body is assumed to be a bad thing, but the exact correlation to specific diseases and problems are not clear. The primary reason is there has not been sufficient time to study the issue long-term and get verifiable results. Many women, however, have shown distinct negative health problems when suffering from leaking silicone implants, complaining of chronic fatigue, neurological and rheumatologic problems. While studies have found conflicting results, it is clear women who have had ruptured silicone implants removed tend to show improved health. The debate continues to this day, but the FDA restricted the use of silicone implants to medically necessary procedures as of 1992.

With the restrictions on silicone implants, saline implants have come on the scene. Originally developed in the 1960s, the implants were overshadowed by silicone until the 1992 ban. Saline implants have a rubberized surface and are filled with a saline solution. In general, they are considered safer than silicone because leaking results in fewer health risks as saline is not toxic in the body. That being said, there have been some complaints regarding saline implants. Specifically, the implants can be difficult to manipulate into the correct form, they can wrinkle and can bottom out - a situation where they sag at the bottom. While these are concerns you should discuss with your plastic surgeon, what is clear is the saline implants do not involve the risks associated with silicone implants.

There is an ongoing debate regarding implants. Since the FDA has banned silicone, it is a debate being won by saline breast implants.

Ricardo de Silva is with PlasticSurgeonPractices.com a directory of plastic surgeons.

Hot Topics In Beauty

    Hairstyles 2007 - The Hottest Look For 2007

    It's a new year and with it comes change and what better way than to enter the new year with a new look and changing your hairstyle will certainly do that.

    Let's look at hairstyle...

    Tummy Tucks And You

    Abdominoplasty, also known as a tummy tuck, is perhaps the best way to shape your lower stomach when an excess of fat accumulates in the area. There are many different types of tummy tucks a person ca...

    How To Lose Belly Fat Fast And Lose Love Handles Fast

    As we age, our metabolism starts to slow down and we start to gain fat in all the wrong places. To make matters worse, it is known that the older we get,the more sedentary our lifestyle will be. This ...

    Anti Aging ~ Choosing The Right Product

    Copyright 2006 Sezeur Skincare

    There are a great many vitamins, minerals, etc to consider when choosing a skin care product especially when your aim is to reduce the signs of aging on your skin. Fro...

    How to Care for your Skin the Natural Way

    Natural skin care is a way to care for your skin without the use of synthetic chemicals in skin care products. Proper hygiene and self-discipline are the biggest factors in natural skin care. A daily ...

    Healthy Eating with Tasty Foods and Still Lose Weight

    It seems as if people do not eat healthy foods because they feel it will not taste as good as regular foods. However, if your health food doesn't taste good, you're eating the wrong health food. Just ...

    Is Laser Eye Surgery Right For You?

    Laser surgery was approved in 1995 for vision correction. Since that time, improvements in technology and techniques have made it one of the most common elective surgeries in the US. Several different...

    Plastic Surgery Do You Need It?

    Very close to 11.9 million underwent cosmetic, both surgical and non surgical, procedures last year. The figure stands at 1,425,900 for the top 5 surgical procedures. Even the trend lines show that th...

    Natural Skin Care And How You Can Benefit

    Natural skin care is the buzz word in today's world - at least, when it comes to wrinkles. With the
    popularity of Botox when it first hit the market, companies were eagerly trying to replicate the...

    Anti-Aging Lotion Secrets: A Path to Beauty.

    Whether its drugstores or retail outlets youll find many kinds of lotions. Variations include crack healing lotions, wrinkle creams, aromatherapy lotions, anti-aging lotions and moisturizing lotions t...

    Know Your Bodybuilding Supplement - L-Arginine

    Arginine is a semi-essential amino acid that the body cannot make naturally. It is found in nuts, seeds, chocolate and raisins.

    Arginine is used by the body in the execution of many important ...

    Onychomycosis - One Of The Many Nail Fungus Out There

    Many natural changes in fingers and toenails come with age. Fine ridges, for example, may start developing from the cuticle of the nail tip. This and other similar changes are common, but they are not...

Most Recent Beauty Supplements

Interesting Today:

Most Recent Beauty Blogs:

Releated to Beauty:

Beauty Links:

Beauty Beauty Rss feeds.